Misleading Pieces
Puzzles

Sometimes a piece comes along that seems to fit the criteria, but not quite. So it makes life a little difficult to say who the manufacturer was. I will place here pieces that might be Ridgway, but also might not. If anyone has similar pieces, or pieces that share features of any piece on this page please let me know, with photographs. Many thanks!

Sprigged Wares

Lilac dessert.

Blue & White Wares

Non-Ridgway Curling Palm

Copies of Hicks 'Priory' shape

Pattern 942

Leaning Rose Moulding dessert shape

Pattern 4476

Pattern 4584

Pattern 4880

Unidentified fractional numbers

Pattern 1/930

Pattern 1/4034

Pattern 3/1178

 

Sprigged Wares

Lilac dessert.

Godden illustrates an example of a dish in his Ridgway Porcelains (Woodbridge, 1985), p.62, Plate 55, which he refers to as 'Unmarked but almost certainly early Ridgway'. Certainly the centre sprig of his illustrated example has been observed on marked Ridgway pieces, but the centre sprigs on the examples illustrated here have not. Also the shape is not one I would associate with Cauldon Place. That must leave an element of doubt. Should a marked example, or some other evidence, turn up, however, I would be happy to reconsider the attribution.

The oval dessert dish is 280mm long and 205mm wide. Probably porcellanised earthenware (the body is slightly translucent).

Oval dessert dish front

Oval dessert dish front detail

Oval dessert dish back

Photos © Paul Mooney 2021

 

The dessert plate is 225mm in diameter. Bone china or porcellanised earthenware.

Lilac dessert plate front

Lilac dessert plate front detail

Lilac dessert plate front detail 2

Lilac dessert plate back

Photos © Bonnie Jean Seiwell ~ Lady in Decadence 2026

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Blue & White Wares

Mostly patterns that copy Ridgway but I don't know who made them.

Non-Ridgway Curling Palm

Once upon a time it was thought that all Curling Palm was made by Job Ridgway. This was because the only marked examples were impressed with his name. Now we know that, just as all Chinoiserie Ruins is not by Davenport, so all Curling Palm is not by Ridgway.

The dinner plate is 252mm in diameter. Pearlware.

Most Ridgway pearlware tableware of this period is flat backed. This dinner plate has a curled in foot with a recessed back. If anyone recognises the shape I would be grateful to hear about it.

Curling Palm dinner plate front

Curling Palm dinner plate side

Curling Palm dinner plate back

Photos © Angela Grant 2023

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Copies of Hicks 'Priory' shape

Hicks & Meigh 'Priory' shape was copied by other manufacturers, mostly in earthenware, but also occasionally in bone china.

Pattern 942

This pattern was thought to be Hicks bone china, but the pattern number is too low for real 'Priory' patterns, and the real ones have moulded flower heads inside the short reverse curves at the edge. The print appears to copy 'Hicks No.81' print but the print does not conform to Hicks style. Manufacturer is unknown.

The dessert plate is 215mm in diameter. Bone china.

Pattern 942 dessert plate front

Pattern 942 dessert plate front detail

Pattern 942 dessert plate front detail 2

Pattern 942 dessert plate back

Pattern 942 dessert plate pattern number

Photos © Paul Mooney 2023

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Leaning Rose Moulding dessert shape

This Leaning Rose shape has long presented a problem of identification. Previously we had seen only Mazarin blue border patterns with the leaning rose edge moulding picked out in gold. They were considered as of uncertain origin, possibly Ridgway. Since the grey border patterns have appeared it has become clear that the style of gilding there seems to fit Alcock better than Ridgway. The numbering system, however, suits neither very well. Patterns in this shape are generally in the 4000s

Pattern 4476

The leaf dessert dish is 248mm long, 225mm wide, and 47mm deep. Bone china.

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 1 front

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 1 front detail

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 1 back

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 1 pattern number

The leaf dessert dish is 248mm long, 225mm wide, and 47mm deep. Bone china.

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 2 front

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 2 front detail

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 2 back

Pattern 4476 leaf dessert dish 2 pattern number

Photos © De France ou d'ailleurs (facebook.com) 2024

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Pattern 4584

The rectangular dessert dish. Bone china.

Pattern 4584 rectangular dessert dish front

Pattern 4584 rectangular dessert dish front detail

Pattern 4584 rectangular dessert dish handle detail

Pattern 4584 rectangular dessert dish back

Pattern 4584 rectangular dessert dish pattern number

Photos © Nick Athanasatos 2022

 

The dessert plates are 238mm in diameter. Bone china.

Pattern 4584 dessert plate 1 front

Pattern 4584 dessert plate 2 front

Pattern 4584 dessert plate 2 front detail

On this pattern the moulding is clearly defined.

Pattern 4584 dessert plate pattern number

Photos © Robert Hawker 2021

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Pattern 4880

The dessert plate is 230mm in diameter. Bone china.

Pattern 4880 dessert plate front

Pattern 4880 dessert plate front detail

Pattern 4880 dessert plate front edge moulding

On this pattern the moulding is hidden by the decoration.

Pattern 4880 dessert plate pattern number

Photos © Dominique Deng 2020

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Unidentified fractional numbers

Pattern 1/930

This was attributed to Alcock, but the 1/ Alcock series was for bone china teawares. At present I am not aware of any manufacturer who made jet ware and used a 1/ number series.

The jug is 185mm tall and 150mm wide. Ebony or jet ware.

Pattern 1/930 jug left side

Pattern 1/930 jug right side

Pattern 1/930 jug base

Pattern 1/930 jug pattern number

Pattern 1/930 jug impressed mark

The impressed "80/2" is probably a date code.

Photos © Tony Curnock 2021

 

Top of Page

Return to Alcock/Duke/Bodley patterns

 

Pattern 1/4034

Several factories have fractional numbering systems. This comport was thought to be by Alcock mostly because the pattern number is in the border colour, but it became apparent that the style is far later than the pattern number would allow. So it is not Alcock and belongs to another factory that used a fractional number system under 1/ as yet undiscovered.

The short dessert comport is 203mm in diameter and 51mm tall. Bone china.

Pattern 1/4034 short dessert comport top

Pattern 1/4034 short dessert comport top detail

Pattern 1/4034 short dessert comport side

Pattern 1/4034 short dessert comport base

Pattern 1/4034 short dessert comport pattern number

Photos © David House 2020

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page

 

Pattern 3/1178

This was attributed originally to Ridgway, Bedford Works, but when a separate tea kettle page was created it became obvious that the attribution was incorrect. Possibly Old Hall, but further examples of shape or prints would be helpful.

The tea kettle. Earthenware.

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle left side

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle spout side

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle spout right side

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle right side

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle handle side

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle lid top

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle base

Pattern 3/1178 tea kettle pattern number

Photos © Clare Tuffin 2022

 

Top of Page

Return to Puzzles, Copies, Replacements page